Ruben Amorim

Manchester United chat
Post Reply
User avatar
Felwin
Legend
Posts: 1904
Joined: 11 years ago
Location: Abroad

Been all but confirmed by Portguese sources and just seen a Romano tweet.

Not sure if it'll be any different than the last 5 lads we've given the job to but we'll see. Highly rated but then so was Ten Hag.
Fuck the Glazers
Legend
Posts: 10817
Joined: 11 years ago

The players have to listen to him, his instructions and carry it out on the pitch. They have to understand the roles and then do them. That's where we may struggle.
Fuck the Glazers
Legend
Posts: 10817
Joined: 11 years ago

There's talk of him taking over in time for Chelsea at weekend. I thought it'd be Ruud til the summer. Fair enough.
User avatar
JoelfuckingGlazer
Legend
Posts: 4576
Joined: 11 years ago

He apparently made changes to Sporting’s training and recovery program that reduced injuries by 20%. He’ll need some of that here.

For me, the biggest encouragement point in terms of data, is that he’s significantly out-performing the salary table in Portugal. Interesting data point is that whilst at Ajax, Hag’s salary budget for the playing squad was double the next nearest, and came close to trebling during his time there. So there was a concerted club effort to level up the squad.
User avatar
dozer
Tim Sherwood
Posts: 4334
Joined: 11 years ago

Would ten hag of Ajax have qualified to be hired under Ineos? Are we buying the next shiny manager or has the club assessed the manager's compatibility better.

User avatar
Felwin
Legend
Posts: 1904
Joined: 11 years ago
Location: Abroad

dozer wrote: 1 month ago Would ten hag of Ajax have qualified to be hired under Ineos? Are we buying the next shiny manager or has the club assessed the manager's compatibility better.

As Joel says, the key difference seems to be that he's done wonders with a smaller budget than the big 2 in Portugal, both at Braga and at Sporting. As Hag seemed to be data driven too (or much more so than the managers before him), I'm very cautious about Amorim being the one but I think the initial signs are slightly better.

I've watched a couple of lads on YouTube talk about how our players will fit his formation and it's a bit concerning that we could be playing without wingers. Not sure our defenders are fast enough to cover the wide areas effectively. My slightly pessimistic prediction is that Amorim will have to adjust like Hag did because our players are shit. Lots and lots of question marks, despite the positives in the way the club have acted.
User avatar
dozer
Tim Sherwood
Posts: 4334
Joined: 11 years ago

Felwin wrote: 1 month ago
dozer wrote: 1 month ago Would ten hag of Ajax have qualified to be hired under Ineos? Are we buying the next shiny manager or has the club assessed the manager's compatibility better.

As Joel says, the key difference seems to be that he's done wonders with a smaller budget than the big 2 in Portugal, both at Braga and at Sporting. As Hag seemed to be data driven too (or much more so than the managers before him), I'm very cautious about Amorim being the one but I think the initial signs are slightly better.

I've watched a couple of lads on YouTube talk about how our players will fit his formation and it's a bit concerning that we could be playing without wingers. Not sure our defenders are fast enough to cover the wide areas effectively. My slightly pessimistic prediction is that Amorim will have to adjust like Hag did because our players are shit. Lots and lots of question marks, despite the positives in the way the club have acted.
Considering we've never had good wingers for a decade, this isn't concerning at all.
User avatar
Felwin
Legend
Posts: 1904
Joined: 11 years ago
Location: Abroad

dozer wrote: 1 month ago Considering we've never had good wingers for a decade, this isn't concerning at all.
It's a fair point but I think our full backs are even worse at providing width. Shaw was the only one and he's going to be replaced by the looks of it.

Maybe we'll see Garnacho and Amad as deputy wing backs? Amass coming in?

I'm just worried there'll be compromises galore again like with Ten Hag, especially with a system United have basically never planned for and never played. I get we can't just magically pull a world class 4-2-3-1 coach out of our arse, and I know the world has probably moved on but we shouldn't expect anything decent until next season IMO. There's going to be lots of hammering square pegs into round holes in the coming month - which is what did for Hag in the end.
User avatar
swampash
Legend
Posts: 3214
Joined: 10 years ago

Wingers are so last millenium…
User avatar
FuB
Site Admin
Posts: 2488
Joined: 9 years ago

Felwin wrote: 1 month ago
dozer wrote: 1 month ago Considering we've never had good wingers for a decade, this isn't concerning at all.
It's a fair point but I think our full backs are even worse at providing width. Shaw was the only one and he's going to be replaced by the looks of it.

Maybe we'll see Garnacho and Amad as deputy wing backs? Amass coming in?

I'm just worried there'll be compromises galore again like with Ten Hag, especially with a system United have basically never planned for and never played. I get we can't just magically pull a world class 4-2-3-1 coach out of our arse, and I know the world has probably moved on but we shouldn't expect anything decent until next season IMO. There's going to be lots of hammering square pegs into round holes in the coming month - which is what did for Hag in the end.
This worries me too. We can't even keep a first choice two centre backs consistently fit so how the fuck are we going to manage three? Also, assuming the wide berths are held by specialist full backs, we end up with just two in the centre of midfield. Presumably Ugarte would be one of them and Bruno the other... so what happens to Mainoo? Or is Bruno put in the middle of the front three, in which case, what happens to Hojlund (and Zirkzee)? Amorim's system requires that all players are highly mobile and that's already a problem for us.
NQAT's official artificial intelligence

I think what Dozer is trying to say is that he knew everything all along and that everyone else has no idea. What he knows and what everyone else knows changes between posts. - Felwin 31/10/2024
Post Reply