Unrealistic summer transfer wankfest III

Manchester United chat
User avatar
dozer
Tim Sherwood
Posts: 4334
Joined: 11 years ago



Seems low. Chelsea sell people who haven't even featured for more.
fat maradona
Legend
Posts: 1448
Joined: 11 years ago

I thought he had potential, shame the manager wants to sell him for peanuts and pay fortunes for not much better.

Does seem low. I think our tactic seems to be sell cheap but with big sell on clause or cheap buy back.
Fuck the Glazers
Legend
Posts: 10818
Joined: 11 years ago

Yeah it's a bit low but it's good to get some income. All goes in the coffers.
User avatar
dozer
Tim Sherwood
Posts: 4334
Joined: 11 years ago

fat maradona wrote: 4 months ago I thought he had potential, shame the manager wants to sell him for peanuts and pay fortunes for not much better.

Does seem low. I think our tactic seems to be sell cheap but with big sell on clause or cheap buy back.
He wasn't signing a new contract so it's a good move to sell him.
User avatar
Felwin
Legend
Posts: 1905
Joined: 11 years ago
Location: Abroad

€10m might seem low but the way the signings are all amortised + the way PSR works, that effectively amounts to €40-50m this season as he's come out of the academy. If he didn't want to re-sign and they think he won't be a top player, fine, take whatver money you can IMO.

Not sure we should be looking to ape Chelsea, even if it's where football is going. Some of these fees for players stink to high heaven of corruption anyway. And now this book value stuff is enshrined in PSR, it's just going to massively inflate fees for academy players playing for the state owned/backed clubs. Just selling one of them for €50m is enough to cover a massive wodge of money that would otherwise have to be proved as revenue, or in Abu Dhabi's case, pumped in by bogus independent sponsors.
User avatar
dozer
Tim Sherwood
Posts: 4334
Joined: 11 years ago

Felwin wrote: 4 months ago €10m might seem low but the way the signings are all amortised + the way PSR works, that effectively amounts to €40-50m this season as he's come out of the academy. If he didn't want to re-sign and they think he won't be a top player, fine, take whatver money you can IMO.

Not sure we should be looking to ape Chelsea, even if it's where football is going. Some of these fees for players stink to high heaven of corruption anyway. And now this book value stuff is enshrined in PSR, it's just going to massively inflate fees for academy players playing for the state owned/backed clubs. Just selling one of them for €50m is enough to cover a massive wodge of money that would otherwise have to be proved as revenue, or in Abu Dhabi's case, pumped in by bogus independent sponsors.
How does this amount to 40-50m now?
User avatar
Felwin
Legend
Posts: 1905
Joined: 11 years ago
Location: Abroad

dozer wrote: 4 months ago
Felwin wrote: 4 months ago €10m might seem low but the way the signings are all amortised + the way PSR works, that effectively amounts to €40-50m this season as he's come out of the academy. If he didn't want to re-sign and they think he won't be a top player, fine, take whatver money you can IMO.

Not sure we should be looking to ape Chelsea, even if it's where football is going. Some of these fees for players stink to high heaven of corruption anyway. And now this book value stuff is enshrined in PSR, it's just going to massively inflate fees for academy players playing for the state owned/backed clubs. Just selling one of them for €50m is enough to cover a massive wodge of money that would otherwise have to be proved as revenue, or in Abu Dhabi's case, pumped in by bogus independent sponsors.
How does this amount to 40-50m now?
He's an academy graduate so his book value is zero (in spite of the fact we paid a couple of million for him from another academy). This means the €10m gets counted as pure profit under PSR, whereas any player we buy this window will be amortised over the length of the contract (usually 3-5 years) so will only show as e.g. €10m for a €50m player on the books.

That's if I've understood what I've read about PSR and amortisation, Maybe the more finacially savvy on here can explain better.
Fuck the Glazers
Legend
Posts: 10818
Joined: 11 years ago

Manchester United have had a €62m (£52m) offer for Leny Yoro accepted by Lille and the defender must decide whether to accept the move, with Real Madrid also interested.

https://www.theguardian.com/football/ar ... -leny-yoro

One of the top young CBs in the world. Would be a great signing by the looks of it.
User avatar
dozer
Tim Sherwood
Posts: 4334
Joined: 11 years ago

Fuck the Glazers wrote: 4 months ago Manchester United have had a €62m (£52m) offer for Leny Yoro accepted by Lille and the defender must decide whether to accept the move, with Real Madrid also interested.

https://www.theguardian.com/football/ar ... -leny-yoro

One of the top young CBs in the world. Would be a great signing by the looks of it.
Apparently it's either him or Delight. I was hoping we ditch Branthwaite because of the ridiculous transfer fee.
User avatar
dozer
Tim Sherwood
Posts: 4334
Joined: 11 years ago

Yoro hasn't agreed personal terms yet. He probably doesn't want to come. I'll be a bit surprised if this deal happens, because he should have signed by now.
Post Reply